US Embassy Explains its Stand on Proposed Ban on Used-clothing

2151 Views Kampala, Uganda

In short
In an email response, US Embassy Spokesman Christopher Brown says the United States shares the concerns of many Ugandans in the private sector and government who worry that a ban on the import of used-clothing is not the best way to protect Ugandas interests and facilitate the development of a domestic textile industry.

The United States Embassy in Uganda has clarified on why it recently expressed concern over a proposed ban on the importation of second-hand clothes.

The Uganda government has in the past proposed a ban on importation of second hand clothers, commonly known as mivumba, in order to protect and promote the local apparels industry. 

But the US Embassy says a ban on the importation of used-clothing would have drastic effects on both Uganda and the US because of the significance of trading in used-clothing.

While paying a courtesy call on the Speaker of Parliament, Rebecca Kadaga, Ambassador Deborah Malac wanted to know how far the proposal had reached. She also expressed her concerns if the proposal was effected.
To date the ban has not been effected although the ping-pongs over the proposal have been ongoing for a while. Most Ugandans also depend on used-clothing.
Uganda Radio Network wrote to the US Embassy Spokesman, Christopher Brown, asking why the US Ambassador would be so concerned about the ban on importation of used-clothing and yet the US also encourages development of the local apparels industry.
URN also sought to know whether Ambassador Malac's concerns were driven more by the need to protect US business interests rather than protection of local interests like those of ordinary Ugandans.
In an email response, Brown says the United States shares the concerns of many Ugandans in the private sector and government who worry that a ban on the import of used-clothing is not the best way to protect Uganda's interests and facilitate the development of a domestic textile industry.
According to Brown, a ban could result in the loss of thousands of jobs for Ugandans who rely on the trade and sale of used clothing for their livelihood. A ban, he says, would also cut off access for many Ugandans to quality and affordable clothing.
Brown further argues that a ban runs counter to the spirit of the African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA), which seeks to open and expand markets and not to restrict access to them.
He explains that AGOA eligibility requirements state that the beneficiaries, like Uganda, must make continual progress toward eliminating barriers to US trade and investment, which would include used clothes.
Brown admits that the East African Community (EAC) is one of the most important markets for US exports of used clothing.
He says the US government estimates that the EAC accounts for one-fifth of total US exports of used clothing, which last year totalled 147 million dollars, equivalent to nearly 500 billion Uganda Shillings.
Brown argues that the proposed ban would have a significant and adverse effect on US employment, adding that the US estimates at least 40,000 US jobs related to the collection, processing and distribution of used clothing would face negative consequences if the ban were effected.
Further, Brown says by restricting market access, this ban would counter the Government of Uganda's key point to US investors - that Uganda is open for business.
According to Brown, AGOA's duty-free access is a tool for Ugandan manufacturers to export competitively to the US. He explains that this tool, and the access it provides Uganda to one of the largest markets in the world, would be jeopardised if Uganda imposed a ban and closed off its market for the used-clothes sector.
Uganda's eligibility under AGOA is presently under review in the US. In addition to what Brown says, the eligibility is also premised on issues of governance and human rights.
Uganda has been performing dismally under AGOA, with duty-free exports declining from about 11 billion Shillings to about four billion Shillings in 2015.
The US government has also extended the life of AGOA up to 2025.
The spokesperson of Kampala Capital Traders' Association, Issa Sekitto, also says a ban on importation and trade in used-clothing would not only be absurd but cruel, inconsiderate and disruptive.
Sekitto says the used-clothing chain is elaborate and supports the livelihood of so many people making any ban, whether abrupt or spread out, disruptive and very dangerous.
According to Sekitto, the government should promote and develop the local textiles industry in the hope that with time they would gradually replace used-clothing if their quality is better. He says the present alternatives from China and other Asian countries simply do not match the quality of used-clothing coming from the West.
Sekitto says in addition to leaving trading in clothing to forces of demand and supply, the users should also be left to make their own choices. He says if a member of parliament can afford expensive clothing that should not mean everyone can.
He says KACITA's position is against any ban, adding that government should leave sentiments and deliver on things like industrialisation and in particular development of the local apparels industry.
Paradoxically, used-clothing is also one of Uganda's major re-exports to neighbours South Sudan, Burundi, the Democratic Republic of Congo, Tanzania and Kenya.


About the author

David Rupiny
In his own words, David Rupiny says, "I am literally a self-trained journalist with over 12 years of experience. Add the formative, student days then I can trace my journalism roots to 1988 when as a fresher in Ordinary Level I used to report for The Giraffe News at St Aloysius College Nyapea in northern Uganda.

In addition to URN for which I have worked for five years now, I have had stints at Radio Paidha, Radio Pacis, Nile FM and KFM. I have also contributed stories for The Crusader, The New Vision and The Monitor. I have also been a contributor for international news organisations like the BBC and Institute for War and Peace Reporting. I am also a local stringer for Radio Netherlands Worldwide.

I am also a media entrepreneur. I founded The West Niler newspaper and now runs Rainbow Media Corporation (Rainbow Radio 88.2 FM in Nebbi). My areas of interest are conflict and peacebuilding, business, climate change, health and children and young people, among others."